ARE WOMEN MUSICIANS MENTIONED IN THE BIBLE? Part 3
So the question is not whether women
were involved in religious and secular music in the Bible, but whether or not
they were used as practicing Temple musicians.
Rothmuller quoted Ambros as saying that "This temple music differs
from its contemporary Egyptian counterpart by the essential circumstance that
Egypt music was already entirely the women's function, whereas in Jerusalem
only men were appointed to its performance." Aaron Rothmuller, The Music of the Jews
p.44, (quoting August Wilhelm Ambrose)
Idelsohn agreed with Rothmuller when he
stated that "Participation of women in the temple choir is nowhere
traceable." A. Z. Idelsohn, Jewish
Music in Its Historical Development, p. 16.
Sendrey, who did
not have a high regard for the authenticity of the Biblical Record, believed
that "In their purificatory zeal, the priestly chroniclers tried
particularly to eliminate anything that might have alluded to, or recalled, the
primitive pagan, pre-Yahvistic rites of the Hebrews, when women participated
regularly in them." Alfred Sendrey, Music in the Social and Religious Life of Antiquity, p. 251. However, Sendrey
did not attempt to document his notion of women participating in pagan
pre-Yahvistic religious music in ancient Israel. Sendrey does concede that, "The Biblical
account contains no direct references to the participation of female singers in
the Temple choir." Ibid, p. 251.
Thought for the Day
It amazes me to
read the works of authors who respect the Biblical Record but entertain the
notion that the authors of Scripture would alter the Record because of personal
prejudice.