Sunday, February 10, 2019

Is Music a Language?—part 6


Is Music a Language?—part 6
           Giving the music part of music a label that is inclusive of all that it “is” and is capable of doing to the whole-life of the individuals who encounter it is problematic. However, I believe that music, as an art form, is “meta” and the term metalanguage   may be used, more or less effectively, to explain that music is characteristically self-referential in that it has power within itself to communicate understandable meaning to the performer and the auditor.
          So, as I have mentioned in my writings and lectures many times, music is at least analogous to a language in that it is capable of communicating meaning and that the meaning it communicates is understandable to those who encounter it.  Although the music part of music i.e. music alone does not communicate verbally, it does non-verbally, and that since the time of Plato and Aristotle, various music philosophers have contended that music’s communication has the power to effect the whole- life of everyone who encounters it. Furthermore, the notion that the music part of music is not capable of communicating anything at all is a Johnny-come-lately theory that is not supported with conclusive evidence that music is a weak and benign art form without any ability to communicate anything at all, or that it has its own meaning that does not relate to life outside of music’s closed bubble.
                    Thought for the Day
Regardless of which side of the debate over whether or not music is a language every Christian musician must come to grips with music’s power.


Saturday, February 9, 2019

Is Music a Language?—part 4


                         Is Music a Language?—part 4
          Everyone brings something to the listening or performing experience.  Part of what each person brings is taken from his or her previous experiences with music, but part of what a performer or listener brings is from the real world outside of music. Therefore, I am a referentialist.  Although I do not adhere to every tenant of the mainstream of philosophical music referentialists, I contend that everyone musics in reference to the real world experiences that he or she has encountered outside the realm of music.  I do not believe that music’s meaning is its own meaning with no relationship to what one has experienced in life.
          Greensburg refers to music as a “non-verbal language”.  When one views the music part of music in this manner it opens new understandings about the power of music without words. This power is at least partially made possible by various unspoken understandings that are molded by the performer’s knowledge of music and cultural and environmental surroundings that will affect that person’s encounter with music.
Thought for the Day
To deny that everyone brings something is to misunderstand that people live in a total world.  This means that whether we wish to recognize it or not, what we derive from our life experiences and from community affects our view of the nature, value and meaning of music.

Friday, February 8, 2019

Is Music a Language?—part 3


Is Music a Language?—part 3
          It appears that Greensburg believes that music has the ability to communicate meaning because of his statement that it “can encode volumes of…information”.  One of the many definitions of encode is to convert some kind of information into a form suitable for the transmission of a message.  So, I believe that music has the power to transmit various kinds of information and that music’s ability to deliver a message to the performer and the listener is “meta” i.e. self-referential.  Therefore, music’s power to communicate functions more efficiently in some aspects than a spoken (verbal) language. 
          The music part of music (the music without words) does have the power to communicate understandable meaning to the performer and the auditor.  However, it is not always easy to predict with certainty exactly what the music will communicate to the listener.  The reason is that music reaction is always referential.  What this means is that all music performers and listeners music both actively and passively  in the perspective of what they bring from their music knowledge and also what they bring from their spiritual, social, psychological, historical, and philosophical backgrounds.  As I have often said in my music lectures and in my writings, no one musics either actively or passively in a vacuum or in a bubble. 
Thought for the Day
Have you ever thought about why some Christian musicians try so hard to deny that music communicates understandable meaning?  What are they trying to prove?

Thursday, February 7, 2019

Is Music a Language?—part 2


 Is Music a Language?—part 2
          It is evident that Greensburg believes that music has understandable meaning, at least in the areas of social, historical, and philosophical information.  It appears from the statement above, that the key factor in the area of music’s ability to communicate meaning to the auditor is the hearer’s understanding of the music.
          The significance of this discussion today is that the notion that no one who knows about music and music philosophy believes that music is a language.  On the contrary, the arguments for and against music being a language is still very much alive.  As I have often written, although there are problems with referring to music as a language, I contend that it is at least analogous to the term language.  I sometimes refer to music as a meta-language simply because it is beyond language is some ways.   
Thought for the Day
If music does not have understandable meaning, then what is the value of music’s meaning.



Wednesday, February 6, 2019

Is Music a Language?—part 1


Is Music a Language?—part 1
          In a recent ad for the Book How to Listen to and Understand Great Music, 3rd Edition by Robert Greenburg this statement was made, “Music is a non-verbal language that can encode volumes of social, historical, and even philosophical information, provided you know how to understand it.”  Greenburg seems to have a modified theory about music being a language.  Some believe that music is a language; others consider it to be a universal language; while still others believe music to be no language at all.
          Greenburg touches on another major argument that questions whether or not we can understand music’s meaning at all.  Some summerly dismiss the question of understanding music’s meaning by simply asserting that music does not have any meaning at all.  Still others believe that music has meaning but that its meaning is an isolated meaning that is not related to life or any understanding that is related in any way to life outside of music’s little bubble.
Thought for the Day
The argument over music being a language in no way settles the question of music’s affect on all who experience it.

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

Aesthetic Experiences with Music


 Aesthetic Experiences with Music
Some music philosophers believe that those who are not knowledgeable concerning a style of music being performed are able to have aesthetic experiences with the music.  As a matter of fact, the MEAE (music education as aesthetic education) movement purports that aesthetic experiences should be one of the major goals of music education.  Praxialists doubt whether students who are not knowledgeable musically can have an aesthetic experience with music. Praxialists also question how often those who are musically knowledgeable actually have aesthetic experiences with music and musicing.  So, there is no general agreement among music philosophies about aesthetic musical experiences.
There is general agreement among music philosophers that some people who perform music or experience musicing are capable of having aesthetic experiences at least part of the time.  Therefore, the Christian musician cannot ignore the philosophical issues that surround aesthetic experiences.  So, all Christian musicians need to consider if and how aesthetic experiences with music do or do not affect sacred musicing. 
Thought for the Day
Christians who ignore aesthetics must somehow believe that if they ignore this phenomena it will go away or at least that effect that aesthetic experiences will not affect them and the people they minister too musically.

Monday, February 4, 2019

Attitude Adjustment


Attitude Adjustment
      My beloved former pastor R.E. Carroll used to tell those of us who worked closely with him that when trouble and misunderstanding arose in his life that he would pray, “Lord handle me.  Lord take care of my attitude.”  Rather than pray that the Lord would change the other guy, he would ask the Lord to change him and his attitude.
       So, when the heat is on, do not try to music unto God until you have had an “attitude adjustment”.  I believe that it is impossible to have an efficacious music ministry when your heart is not prepared or “fixed”.  I say again, heart fixing is absolutely necessary before you music unto God.  It doesn’t do much good to tune your harp until you have tuned your heart.

Thought for the Day
Being upset or angry at someone else over a long period of time hurts you much more than the person with whom you are angry.



Sunday, February 3, 2019

Singing under Stress


Singing under Stress
Psalm 57:7 My heart is fixed, O God, my heart is fixed:  I will sing and give praise. 
       Evidently David prepared this Psalm for the chief Levite musician during the time he was fleeing from King Saul.  While under great stress the Psalmist David found it necessary to prepare his heart before he could sing and give praise unto God.  This Scripture says that David “fixed his heart.  The Hebrew word kuwn (3559) means that David prepared his heart so that he could sing and rejoice, even though he was under great pressure from King Saul.
       Christian musicians who are constantly working with others will from time to time find themselves under great stress.  At such times there will be situations that are capable of causing hard feelings and misunderstandings.  Dealing with these situations will require much heart preparation.  If the Christian musician does not take time to make the necessary heart “fixing”, burnout is sure to happen.  

Prayer for the Day
Dear Lord, as I come to you in prayer at this moment, I want to thank You for Your sustaining grace in times of stress.  I am asking You to help me to trust that You will never let any stress overtake me.  However, I need Your help at this moment.  Lord help me to not lean on my own understanding or strength.  I confess to You that when the pressure is on, I do not trust my own inner strength to take me through the time of trouble and stress.  Here I am Lord. Please help me just now.  This I am praying in Your strong name.  Amen.

Saturday, February 2, 2019

Help Me to Seek Peace


Help Me to Seek Peace
1 Peter 3:10-12 For he that will love life, and see good days, let him refrain his tongue from evil, and his lips that they speak no guile: Let him eschew evil, and do good; let him seek peace, and ensue it.  For the eyes of the Lord are over the righteous, and his ears are open unto their prayers: but the face of the Lord is against them that do evil.
          Wow!  The lips and tongue can get a Christian musician in much trouble.  It seems that some musicians will have to remain silent to keep out of trouble.  How can a plain-spoken musician stay out of trouble?  The Bible teaches that this person must run from i.e. eschew evil.  Evil speaking is , of course, evil! 
          While the Christian is running from evil speech, he or she must seek peace.  This musician may find it difficult to live peaceably with others, bit the Bible teaches that we are to not only seek peace but also ensue it.  This means that the sincere, earnest Christian musician must not only seek to be peaceful but also to pursue it earnestly.  The Christian musician must do this because nothing that a musician does or thinks escapes the eyes of the Lord.

Prayer for the Day
Lord, I am aware that the eyes of the Lord are over the righteous.  However, I am also aware that Your ears are open unto my prayers.  Lord, I am asking You to help me to seek peace with those with whom I am ministering and to help me to make peace with others a way of life.  I can not do this with everyone all the time if You do not help me.  Please hover over my tongue and my lips.  Please guard my heart so that I will do good to those who do not agree with me.  This I am praying in Your wise and wonderful name.  Amen.

Friday, February 1, 2019

Thank you for a Great Month of January 2019


Thank you for a Great Month of January 2019      
            This month was the 70th month of my blog which contained devotional and philosophical thoughts for Christian musicians. I have written over 3,380 posts since this blog was started in January of 2013. There have been several times this year when I have experienced a certain amount of writer’s burnout.  However, I am praying that my posts in 2019 will stimulate both the regular and new blog members to remain faithful to their musical ministries.  The over 3,200 page views of my blog this month were experienced by people who read a mixture of philosophical and devotional thoughts.  We have had over 138,200 page-views since the blog was started in January of 2013.  Since I started this blog the page views have come from 131 different countries. It is interesting to note that a little over one half of the total page views since we began in January 2013 have come from the United States and the other one half have come from a varied combination of 130 countries scattered around the world.
            These views have come from Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, American Samoa, Argentina, Armenia, Angola,  Aruba, Austria, Australia, Azerbaijan, Barbados, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Belarus, Belgium, Bolivia, Bosnia, Brazil, Bulgaria, Cambodia, Canada, Cayman Islands, Chile, China, Czechia , Czech Republic,  Colombia, Congo [DRC], Costa Rica, Croatia, Denmark, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Egypt, Estonia Ethiopia, Fiji, France, Finland, Georgia, Germany, Ghana, Greece, Guatemala, Guyana, Herzegovina, Honduras, Hong Kong,  Iceland, India, Indonesia, Iraq, Ireland (Republic of),  Iran, Israel, Italy, Japan, Jordon, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kosovo, Kuwait, Lebanon, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Macedonia (FYROM) Macau, Madagascar, Malaysia, Mauritius, Malta Mexico, Moldova, Mongolia,  Morocco, Mozambique, Myanmar (Burma), Nepal, Netherlands, Netherlands (Antilles) New Zealand, Nigeria, Northern Ireland, Oman, Palestine, Paraguay, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, Peru. Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Porto Rico, Qatar, Réunion, Romania, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Serbia, Sierra Leone, Singapore, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Syria, Taiwan, Tanzania, Thailand,  Tunisia, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Turks & Caicos Islands, Uganda, Ukraine, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, Unknown Region, Uruguay, Venezuela, Vietnam, USA, Zambia and Zimbabwe.
            We would like to welcome the countries of Bosnia, Herzegovina, Lebanon and Kosovo to our blog family.
             The ten countries with the most page views this month were: United States, United Arab Emirates, Russia, Unknown region,  Germany, , Indonesia, France, Brazil, Portugal, and South Korea.